Games Contact us
Select Page
⚡ TL;DR
In the US, almost every car purchase starts online. Three listing marketplaces dominate dealer inventory — CarGurus (the most visited, $907 million revenue in 2025, 34,409 paying dealers worldwide), Cars.com and Cox Automotive’s Autotrader — and make money mainly from dealer subscriptions. Online retailers Carvana (596,641 retail units in 2025) and CarMax sell their own inventory and buy cars from consumers with instant offers. Private sellers use Facebook Marketplace, Craigslist and eBay Motors, while enthusiasts use auction sites such as Bring a Trailer and Cars & Bids. Research sites — Kelley Blue Book, Edmunds — anchor prices.

US online car marketplaces have reshaped how Americans buy and sell cars. Shoppers compare thousands of listings, price ratings and dealer reviews before setting foot in a dealership, and sellers can get instant cash offers from national retailers in minutes. Behind the consumer experience is a fierce business battle for dealer advertising budgets and for the supply of used cars. This guide explains the main platforms in 2026, how they make money and which ones suit buyers, private sellers and dealers. It belongs to the Car Sales Markets hub, alongside our US market overview and US distribution guide.

Key Takeaways

Which is the biggest US car marketplace?
CarGurus describes itself as the most visited automotive shopping site in the US; Cars.com and Autotrader are its main listing rivals.

How do these sites make money?
Mostly from dealers: monthly listing subscriptions, premium placement, leads, digital marketing and software — consumers browse for free.

Where should private sellers go?
Facebook Marketplace for local reach, instant-offer services (Carvana, CarMax, marketplace offers) for speed, and auction sites such as Bring a Trailer for enthusiast cars.

How do Americans use online car marketplaces?

The typical US car buyer spends many hours researching online before buying, visits fewer dealerships than a decade ago and arrives with a specific car in mind. Listing marketplaces aggregate dealer inventory — new and used — with prices, photos, vehicle history reports and dealer reviews, and add tools such as price ratings, financing pre-qualification and trade-in estimates. Research sites provide valuations and reviews. Online retailers let buyers complete the purchase online with delivery.

For dealers, marketplaces are the main source of online leads. A dealer typically lists its entire inventory on several marketplaces, pays a monthly subscription to each, and buys extra visibility. The marketplaces compete on traffic, lead quality and the software and data products they bundle — inventory pricing, digital retail and trade-in tools — which is why they increasingly look like software companies.

Selected US car marketplace metrics, 2025CarGurus revenue ($M)907Carvana retail units (thousand)597CarGurus paying dealers (thousand)34.4CarGurus US paying dealers (thousand)26
Sources: CarGurus Q4/FY2025 results (19 Feb 2026); Carvana FY2025 results (18 Feb 2026).

How does CarGurus work?

CarGurus, founded in 2006 in Cambridge, Massachusetts, built its audience on price transparency: every listing gets a deal rating — Great, Good, Fair, High or Overpriced — based on CarGurus’ Instant Market Value estimate, and listings can be sorted by deal quality. Consumers browse free. Dealers can list basic inventory free, but most pay for a higher subscription tier that adds visibility, dealership branding, phone, chat and email leads and market analytics.

CarGurus reported full-year 2025 revenue of $907 million, up 14% for the second straight year, with 26,049 US and 8,360 international paying dealers. In 2025 it wound down its CarOffer wholesale business, refocusing on the marketplace and dealer software such as its pricing, inventory and digital-deal tools. It also operates in Canada and the UK, where it competes with Auto Trader. Private sellers can list cars on CarGurus or request an instant offer through partner dealers. Read our full CarGurus review.

How do Cars.com and Autotrader compare?

Cars.com, operated by Cars Commerce, is the second-largest listing marketplace and has diversified into dealer software: Dealer Inspire (dealer websites and digital marketing), AccuTrade (vehicle appraisal and acquisition) and CreditIQ (financing). Its model is subscription-based, with dealers paying for listings and add-on products; it serves tens of thousands of dealer customers.

Autotrader is owned by Cox Automotive, the private conglomerate that also owns Kelley Blue Book, Manheim auctions, vAuto inventory software, Dealer.com websites, Dealertrack finance and the VinSolutions CRM. That ecosystem gives Autotrader deep data and integration with dealers’ operations: KBB’s values appear in Autotrader listings, vAuto prices inventory based on market data, and Manheim provides wholesale exit routes. For dealers, Cox’s bundles are a strategic choice as much as an advertising buy.

💡 Pro Tip: Dealers should measure marketplaces on cost per sold vehicle, not cost per lead. Attribute sales to source using CRM and DMS data, compare each site’s subscription and premium spend against vehicles sold from its leads, and renegotiate tiers quarterly. Our automotive CRM comparison covers the tools that make this attribution possible.

How do Carvana and CarMax sell cars online?

Carvana and CarMax are not marketplaces but retailers: they own the cars they sell. Carvana sells entirely online, with home delivery or pickup at its car “vending machines”, a seven-day return policy and integrated financing. After nearly collapsing in 2022–2023, it grew retail units 43% to 596,641 in 2025, earned a record $1.9 billion net income, and operates reconditioning centres including former ADESA auction sites it acquired. It has set a goal of selling 3 million retail units a year in the 2030s.

CarMax, the largest used-car retailer by stores, runs an omnichannel model: buyers can shop online and complete the transaction at home or in a store. Its retail volumes declined in 2025 amid leadership changes and cost pressures. CarMax also owns Edmunds, the research and reviews site, and runs CarMax Auto Finance.

Both companies are major buyers of cars from consumers through instant offers: enter the VIN or plate and mileage, answer condition questions, receive an offer valid for several days, and sell at a location or with pickup. That competition for supply is one of the defining features of today’s US used market.

Where do private sellers sell cars online in the US?

Private sellers have several options. Facebook Marketplace has become the largest venue for local private car sales because it is free and has huge reach; Craigslist remains popular in some regions; eBay Motors offers auction and fixed-price listings with national reach and buyer protections for some transactions. Listing marketplaces such as CarGurus, Autotrader and Cars.com accept private listings, sometimes for a fee, with features like secure payment and title transfer support.

For enthusiast, classic and collector cars, curated online auctions dominate: Bring a Trailer (owned by Hearst) runs high-profile week-long auctions with detailed listings and active comment sections; Cars & Bids focuses on modern enthusiast cars from the 1980s onward; and PCARMARKET specialises in Porsches and other collectibles. Sellers pay a listing fee and buyers pay a buyer’s premium.

Many private sellers simply compare instant offers from Carvana, CarMax, the marketplaces and local dealers with the price they could get privately, and accept the convenience premium. Our guide to the best sites to sell a car in the US ranks the options.

⚠️ Risk: Private car sales online carry fraud risk: fake escrow services, overpayment cheque scams, title washing and curbstoning (unlicensed dealers posing as private sellers). Meet in safe locations, verify payment with the bank before releasing the title, run a vehicle history report and check the title status with the state DMV.

What role do research and valuation sites play?

Kelley Blue Book (Cox Automotive), Edmunds (CarMax) and J.D. Power’s valuation guides anchor price expectations. KBB’s values are used by consumers to judge trade-in offers and by marketplaces in deal ratings; Edmunds provides reviews and “True Market Value”; NADA guides, now J.D. Power, are used by lenders. Vehicle history providers Carfax and AutoCheck (Experian) are integrated into most marketplaces and are essential to buyers’ trust.

Because these sites own the reference prices, they influence negotiations far beyond their own traffic. Dealers price inventory against market data from vAuto, CarGurus and other tools; buyers compare KBB values; lenders use J.D. Power or KBB values for loan-to-value calculations.

Platform Type Business model Best for
CarGurus Listing marketplace Dealer subscriptions, leads, software Buyers wanting deal ratings; dealers wanting traffic
Cars.com Listing marketplace + dealer software Subscriptions, Dealer Inspire, AccuTrade Dealers wanting bundled marketing tools
Autotrader / KBB Marketplace + valuation (Cox) Subscriptions, data, Cox ecosystem Dealers in the Cox stack; buyers using KBB
Carvana Online retailer Retail margin, finance, wholesale Fully online buying and instant offers
CarMax / Edmunds Omnichannel retailer + research Retail margin, CarMax Auto Finance Buyers wanting stores plus online; Edmunds reviews
Facebook Marketplace Classifieds Free for private sellers Local private sales
eBay Motors Auction/classifieds Listing and success fees National private reach, parts
Bring a Trailer, Cars & Bids Enthusiast auctions Seller fees + buyer premium Collector and enthusiast cars

How do marketplaces compete for dealers in 2026?

Competition among US marketplaces has shifted from traffic to tools. Each platform now sells a stack: inventory pricing analytics, digital deal-building that lets shoppers structure a purchase online, trade-in acquisition tools and lead-management integrations. CarGurus pushed into dealer data and digital retail; Cars Commerce bought dealer-tech businesses; Cox bundles everything from KBB to the DMS.

Artificial intelligence is the newest front: AI-written listing descriptions, conversational search (“find me a three-row hybrid under $35,000 within 50 miles”), automated responses to leads and AI-driven pricing. Platforms also experiment with transaction features — online deposits, reservation and payment — that move them closer to e-commerce.

For dealers, the practical choice is not which single site to use but how to allocate budget across several, track results and integrate leads into the CRM. For consumers, the best strategy is to use more than one marketplace, compare deal ratings with valuation guides, and get at least two instant offers before trading in.

How do US marketplaces compare with other countries?

The US is unusual in having three strong listing marketplaces competing nationally, plus powerful online retailers. In most other markets one or two platforms dominate: Auto Trader in the UK, mobile.de and AutoScout24 in Germany, sahibinden.com in Türkiye, Autohome and Dongchedi in China. The US market’s fragmentation gives dealers more negotiating power over advertising prices — and gives consumers more ways to compare.

What should buyers check before buying a car through a US marketplace?

Use the marketplace as a research tool, then verify. Check the deal rating against KBB or Edmunds values; read the vehicle history report for accidents, title brands and ownership; confirm the dealer’s documentation fee and add-ons, which can add hundreds or thousands of dollars to the advertised price; check reviews of the dealer, not just the car; and for remote purchases, understand delivery fees, return policies and how warranty service will work locally. Get financing pre-approval from a bank or credit union to compare with dealer financing — marketplaces’ pre-qualification tools help, but a firm offer gives you leverage.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the best website to buy a used car in the US?

CarGurus, Cars.com and Autotrader list the most dealer inventory and are best for comparison; Carvana and CarMax are best if you want to buy online from a retailer with a return policy.

Is it free to sell a car on Facebook Marketplace?

Yes, listing a car on Facebook Marketplace is free for private sellers. Payment and title transfer are handled between buyer and seller.

How do CarGurus deal ratings work?

CarGurus estimates an Instant Market Value for each car based on comparable listings and sales, then labels the asking price as a Great, Good or Fair deal, or High or Overpriced.

Do Carvana and CarMax buy cars?

Yes. Both make instant online offers based on your car’s details and condition, valid for several days, and pay at pickup or drop-off.

Last Updated: November 2026 · Reviewed by the Kurums Sales editorial team. Figures are as reported by the cited associations, regulators and companies at the time of writing; fees, rules and volumes change — verify before acting.

Discover more from Kurums | Business Intelligence

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading