Booking.com won court permission on 28 October 2026 to make 40% office attendance mandatory, and its works council said on 10 November that it will appeal. The case shows how a Dutch employer moves from “encouraged” to “required”: a written proposal, a consent request and, if consent is refused, a judge who tests the reasons. A different Amsterdam employer lost a similar case in 2025 because its reasoning was too general. The UK and US have no consent step, but Barclays, NatWest and Skydance show that the dispute then moves to unions and exits. Build the evidence file before announcing a mandate, not after.
Most return-to-office stories start with a memo from the chief executive. The Booking.com dispute is more useful to practitioners because it shows what an employer has to prove, and to whom, before an attendance guideline becomes a rule. In the Netherlands that question went to a judge and is now heading to a higher court.
Our Notes briefing on the works council’s appeal sets out the announcement, and an earlier note covers the ruling. This analysis looks instead at the consent mechanics, how they compare with Germany, the UK and the US, and what a defensible move to mandatory attendance looks like.
This is not legal advice. Works council and employment rules differ by country and employer; check your position with employment counsel.
What happened, and what the coverage adds
Booking.com had advised staff since 2022 to spend 40% of their working time in the office. DutchNews, citing the Financieele Dagblad, reported average attendance of 27%. Management decided to make the guideline mandatory, the works council refused to endorse the plan, and the company went to court. The Amsterdam subdistrict court ruled for the company on 28 October. On 10 November NL Times, citing Reuters, reported that the works council will appeal.
The details matter more than the headline:
- The plan was scaled back. DutchNews reports that the company had considered 50% or 60% before settling on 40%.
- The design left room for choice. One office day would be agreed within each team and the other chosen by the employee, according to DutchNews. DutchReview says attendance is measured monthly.
- There were safeguards. NL Times reports a six-month transition period. DutchReview adds a hardship clause and says the court expects enough workspaces for everyone who comes in.
- The works council’s case is about proof. It told the court there was “no business case” for compulsion, DutchNews reported. Its appeal argues that the judge did not apply all the criteria set by the Supreme Court and that the company did not substantively prove that mandatory days would achieve its goals.
- Other employers moved quickly. NL Times reports that VodafoneZiggo plans three office days a week and ABN Amro wants staff in for at least half the week. In a survey of more than 3,000 members of the union FNV, half said they would consider another job if ordered back.
We could not open the judgment itself, so this article relies on press and law-firm summaries. None of the reports says whether the appeal suspends the ruling.
What Google Trends shows
We compared four search terms worldwide over the past 90 days. Values are relative: 100 is the highest point in the comparison, which “hybrid work” reached on 20 September. “Return to office” peaked the same day at 53. Both have faded. “Return to office” averaged 12.4 over the first 60 days of the window and 4.9 over the last seven; “hybrid work” fell from 25.2 to 8.9.
“Booking.com office” barely registers: a peak of 4, a reading of 1 on the day of the ruling and 0 on the day of the appeal. “Works council” peaked at 64 on 19 August, well before the case, and averaged 1.7 in the last week.
Public attention goes to big-brand mandates. Setting aside unrelated noise, the rising queries around “return to office” are led by “barclays hit by staff backlash over return to office rules” and “natwest return to office requirements” (both marked Breakout), then “skydance five day return to office” (+4,900%). The Booking.com case is a specialist employment-law story. Your workforce may not have heard of it, but your works council’s advisers have.
How consent works under the Dutch Works Councils Act
The mechanism is in Article 27 of the Works Councils Act (WOR), which we read in the English translation published by the Social and Economic Council (SER):
- Consent is required to lay down, amend or withdraw certain regulations covering all staff or a group of them. The list in Article 27(1) includes working hours, working conditions and attendance monitoring.
- The proposal must be in writing, with reasons and expected consequences for staff, and discussed in at least one consultation meeting before the council takes a final position (Article 27(2)).
- If consent is refused, the employer may go to the subdistrict judge, who grants permission only if the refusal is unreasonable or the decision is required for important organisational, economic or social reasons (Article 27(4)).
- A decision taken without consent or permission is invalid if the works council invokes this in writing within one month (Article 27(5)).
Hybrid working is not named in the list. In a June 2025 Amsterdam case summarised by the law firm act legal, the subdistrict court held that a hybrid work policy falls within the consent right because limiting remote work affects commuting time, health and work-life balance.
Two Amsterdam rulings, two outcomes
A Hogan Lovells note of 11 November sets two decisions side by side. It does not name the employers, but the first matches the reported Booking.com ruling in date and facts.
| 28 October 2026 | 3 June 2025 | |
|---|---|---|
| Proposal | At least 40% office time | From two to three office days |
| Employer’s record | Extensive consultation, reduced original requirement, flexibility for exceptional circumstances | Reasons not sufficiently substantiated |
| Outcome | Permission granted | Permission refused |
The firm’s takeaways are that employers “do not necessarily need to show that greater office attendance is indispensable”, but that “international alignment and general references to productivity or corporate culture may not be enough”. The appeal will test where that line sits.
Germany, the UK and the US in outline
Germany. A Hogan Lovells client note describes “enforceable co-determination” on social matters, including the distribution of working hours across the week and the organisation of mobile work. If employer and works council cannot agree, either can go to a conciliation board with a neutral chair, which makes a binding decision. Until then the employer cannot implement the measure. Whether a particular attendance rule falls within these rights is a question for German counsel.
United Kingdom. There is no consent step; the constraints are individual. Gov.uk states that all employees can request flexible working, including where they work, from their first day, and that employers must handle requests in a “reasonable manner”. Clyde & Co adds that staff may claim implied contractual rights from long-term hybrid arrangements, and that refusals touching disability or caring responsibilities can lead to discrimination claims with uncapped compensation.
United States. The limit that the US commentary we read concentrates on is disability accommodation. Troutman Pepper Locke writes that employers “cannot categorically deny remote work requests from employees with disabilities” because of a return-to-office policy.
What Barclays, NatWest and Skydance show
- Barclays. Fortune reported in September that the bank planned to raise UK attendance from two days to three, and four for senior staff, from October. The union Unite asked for a one-off payment, travel support and exemptions for commutes of 40 minutes or more. FStech reported on 30 September that the requirement was delayed to the start of 2027 for staff who obtain line-manager approval.
- NatWest. Insurance Business reported on 21 October that from February about 13,500 “remote-first” staff and about 17,000 hybrid workers must attend at least twice a week. Unite says the bank bypassed a consultation agreed as part of a pay deal.
- Skydance. HRD America reported that a 26 October memo set a five-day office week, phased by location, alongside a one-time voluntary buyout. The memo said “not everyone will see their future here”.
The complaints echo the Dutch case: missing evidence, bypassed consultation and too little allowance for individual circumstances. A works council forces the employer to answer these points before implementation. Elsewhere the employer answers them afterwards, in public, through delays, union campaigns or departures.
A playbook for moving from “encouraged” to “required”
- Define the problem locally. State what is not working under the voluntary guideline, for which teams, using your own attendance, training and survey data. If staff surveys point the other way, address that directly.
- Write the business case as if a judge will read it. Link each objective to a reason why a requirement, and not encouragement, is needed.
- Map representation rights before any announcement. List where consent, co-determination or agreed consultation applies, and review contracts and past communications for commitments on remote work.
- Keep a consultation record. Date each meeting, record objections and answers, and show what you changed in response.
- Choose the least intrusive design. A percentage measured monthly, with one team day and one free day, is easier to defend than fixed days for all.
- Announce the transition period with the policy. Six months featured in the Dutch ruling. Barclays’ transitional measures came after the backlash and were reported as a delay.
- Publish the exceptions route. Set written criteria for hardship, caring and health, and handle disability and flexible-working requests individually.
- Check capacity. Confirm desks and meeting rooms before the start date. At the Booking.com hearing, one employee described commuting an hour to spend the day on video calls.
- Agree how you will measure. Attendance monitoring is itself on the Dutch consent list. Commit to reviewing outcomes, including turnover, on a set date.
For related guidance, see the Kurums HR compliance and employment law hub.
What to watch next
- The Booking.com appeal: no hearing date has been reported.
- VodafoneZiggo and ABN Amro: whether their works councils consent.
- Start of 2027: Barclays’ deferred three-day requirement.
- February 2027: NatWest’s two-day minimum.
- Autumn 2027: expected UK flexible-working reforms under the Employment Rights Act 2025, according to Clyde & Co.
Remote work policy, Decoded: the 90-second version
Plain English, one pop-culture comparison, and the sentence to say in the meeting. Part of Kurums Decoded.
Frequently asked questions
Can any Dutch employer now mandate two office days?
No. DutchReview notes that the court weighed the specific elements of Booking.com’s plan, and the 2025 Amsterdam decision went the other way on weaker reasoning.
Is the mandate on hold while the appeal runs?
The reports we read do not say. Confirm the procedural status with counsel before relying on a first-instance ruling.
We have no works council. Does this matter to us?
Yes, as a checklist. Unions at Barclays and NatWest raised similar points, and individual requests still have to be handled lawfully.
Sources and further reading
- NL Times on the appeal (10 November 2026, citing Reuters).
- DutchNews: the ruling, the hearing, the background; DutchReview.
- SER: Works Councils Act, English translation.
- Hogan Lovells on Dutch return-to-office rulings; act legal on the 2025 case; Hogan Lovells on Germany.
- Gov.uk: Flexible working; Clyde & Co; Troutman Pepper Locke.
- Barclays: Fortune, FStech. NatWest: Insurance Business. Skydance: HRD America.
- Google Trends: four-term comparison, past 90 days.
Discover more from Kurums | Business Intelligence
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.