On 16 November 2026, deputy assistant attorney general Charlie Beller told a New York conference that the Justice Department is focused on how behavioral commitments can act as a mitigating factor for competition concerns, particularly where asset sales are hard to arrange. He pointed to the Department’s decision on 6 November to close its investigation of Fox Corp.’s $22 billion acquisition of Roku after Fox made four commitments. Those commitments were set out in a press release and were not filed in court. On 18 November, Newsmax sued in federal court in San Jose to unwind the deal, calling the commitments “ill-defined” with “no evident enforcement mechanism”. Taken together, the two events show that the door to conduct-based clearance is open, and that a clearance obtained this way may not end a merging party’s litigation risk.
For most of the past decade, the advice to a company with a merger that raised competition questions was consistent: expect to sell something. Both the Biden administration and the first Trump administration favoured structural remedies and largely rejected settlements built on promises about future conduct, according to Bloomberg’s account of the shift.
That advice now needs revising. A senior Antitrust Division official has said in public that conduct commitments can carry weight, and the Division has cleared a large media deal on that basis. Within twelve days, a competitor filed a private lawsuit attacking the same commitments. This article explains what was said, how the Fox–Roku clearance was structured, what the Newsmax complaint alleges and what in-house counsel and deal teams should do differently. It extends our short news note on the remarks.
This is general analysis, not legal advice. Merger review turns on the facts of each transaction, and the allegations in a complaint are unproven. Consult antitrust counsel on any live deal.
Structural and behavioral remedies in brief
| Structural remedy | Behavioral remedy | |
|---|---|---|
| What it is | Sale of a business, brand, plant or other asset to a buyer the agency accepts | A promise about future conduct: access, non-discrimination, firewalls, licensing terms |
| Duration | Permanent once the sale closes | Time-limited, often three to ten years |
| Oversight | Low after the sale | Continuing, and dependent on someone checking compliance |
| Typical use | Mergers of direct competitors | Vertical deals, where one party supplies or distributes for rivals |
| Main weakness | May destroy deal value, or no suitable buyer exists | Hard to define, monitor and enforce |
What the officials said
Bloomberg reported that Beller said the Department has been focused on “how behavioral commitments or remedies serve” as “a mitigating factor” for competition concerns, especially in industries where asset sales may be more difficult to arrange. The report adds that his comment sheds light on how the Department may approach its review of Nvidia’s $13 billion acquisition of the AI model company Hugging Face.
The Federal Trade Commission, which shares merger review with the Justice Department, sounded more reserved at the same event. Behavioral remedies remain “disfavored and rare”, said David Shaw, the agency’s second-ranking competition official, though regulators sometimes have reasons to accept them. “In some cases, blocking the deal might not be the optimum result,” he said, adding that winning a court challenge is not always realistic.
So the position differs by agency. Which agency reviews a deal is decided between the two of them, largely by industry experience, and parties do not get to choose. A remedy strategy that fits one may not fit the other. The FTC’s current approach to a horizontal deal is illustrated by its challenge to the Covetrus–MWI merger.
How Fox–Roku was cleared
Fox and Roku announced the closing of their transaction on the morning of 6 November, less than five months after the deal was proposed and well ahead of the first-half 2027 window the companies had projected. Later that day the Justice Department said in a press release that it would not challenge the deal.
According to Competition Policy International’s summary, the review focused on whether Fox could use Roku’s platform to favour its own services, including Tubi and Fox One. The Department concluded that the acquisition was unlikely to substantially reduce competition, citing alternative streaming platforms and Roku’s commercial incentive to keep offering a broad range of programming. It had issued second requests to both companies in September.
The commitments, as described by The Hollywood Reporter, Deadline and Competition Policy International, are these:
- Carriage. Roku will continue to carry non-Fox content for at least three years and remain “an open and neutral content partner”.
- Search and placement. Competing services will not be pushed down in search results, and users keep the ability to arrange apps on their home screens.
- Data products. Fox will continue to provide certain data products to third parties on commercially reasonable terms.
- Firewalls. Safeguards on rivals’ competitively sensitive data, such as what users search for and watch, stay in place until at least 2029.
The Department said it would keep monitoring the sector and could act if circumstances change.
The procedural point: no consent decree
The form of the clearance is as important as its content. When the Justice Department settles a merger case, it normally files a proposed consent decree in federal court. Under the Tunney Act, a law dating from the Watergate era, the government must then explain why the settlement is in the public interest, the public may comment, the companies must disclose their contacts with the executive branch, and a judge reviews the result. The decree becomes a court order that can be enforced through contempt proceedings.
None of that happened here. Bloomberg reported that the Department opted against filing the Fox–Roku commitments in court. They exist as statements in a press release. Bloomberg also notes that senior Democrats in Congress have proposed amending the Tunney Act to require more disclosure and a stronger standard of review.
For the merging parties, this route is faster and less public. The price is that the commitments have no judge behind them, and that is the opening Newsmax has used.
What Newsmax alleges
Newsmax filed its complaint on 18 November. The following are its allegations as reported by Deadline and The Hollywood Reporter:
- Market share. The Roku Channel accounts for roughly 42% of viewing time on free ad-supported streaming services and Fox’s Tubi for more than 28%, citing Nielsen data. The complaint says a combined share of about 71% should be presumed anticompetitive.
- Departure from practice. “DOJ virtually never clears a transaction combining the two leading competitors in a concentrated market; it typically demands divestiture of one or the other to protect competition.”
- Enforceability. A consent decree “ensures that the merging parties’ obligations are clear and enforceable – something four bullet points in a press release fail to achieve.”
- The term sheet. After closing, Newsmax says it asked Fox for a binding contract reflecting the commitments and sent a term sheet. It says Fox rejected the request and made no counter-proposal.
- Relief sought. An injunction, including unwinding the merger unless Fox divests Tubi or The Roku Channel.
Fox rejects the claims. “Newsmax’s complaint, which comes after a rigorous review process by regulatory agencies, is wholly without merit,” a spokesperson said. “Upon closing, we commenced actively integrating this approved transaction for the benefit of consumers, partners and other stakeholders.”
Two cautions apply. Newsmax is a commercial rival with separate litigation pending against Fox, and a court has not yet tested its market definition or its standing. But the suit illustrates a point of law that deal teams sometimes forget. An agency’s decision not to challenge a merger does not immunise it. Competitors, customers and state attorneys general can bring their own actions, before or after closing.
What Google Trends shows
We compared five search terms in the United States over the past 90 days. “Antitrust” averaged 15 on Google’s shared scale, with a peak of 100 on 27 September. “Fox Roku” averaged 3, peaked at 12 on 13 September and has risen from an average of 2.0 in the first month of the period to 4.6 over the past two weeks. “Divestiture” averaged 1. “Merger review” and “behavioral remedies” did not register.
The related queries show how the public sees the deal. Most are consumer questions such as “fox on roku” and “does roku have fox”. Breakout queries include “fox buys roku 22 billion” and “fox corp roku merger update”. For “divestiture”, the fastest riser is “kroger albertsons store divestiture dispute”, up 400%, a reminder that asset-sale remedies generate their own disputes. For “merger review”, the leading queries concern the Union Pacific–Norfolk Southern and NextEra transactions.
The remedy debate is invisible to general audiences. It is being conducted among lawyers, rivals and members of Congress, and those are the groups whose reaction a deal team needs to plan for.
Seven lessons for deal teams
- Put a conduct package on the table early, where it fits. In a vertical deal reviewed by the Justice Department, a well-drafted set of access and non-discrimination commitments is now a credible opening position. At the FTC, expect more resistance.
- Draft commitments as if a judge will read them. Define the products, the counterparties, the duration and the test for “commercially reasonable”. Vague wording is the first thing an opponent will quote.
- Decide how third parties can rely on them. Fox was asked for a binding agreement within days of closing. Parties should settle in advance whether they will offer contractual versions of their commitments to distributors, suppliers or content partners, and on what terms. A refusal will appear in the complaint.
- Price in private and state litigation. An informal clearance leaves more room for it. Merger agreements should address who bears the cost and risk of post-closing challenges, and integration plans should take account of any assets that a plaintiff asks a court to hold separate.
- Build compliance before closing. Assign an owner, a reporting line to the general counsel, training for commercial teams and an audit trail. A broken commitment is evidence in the next investigation.
- Record your contacts. Scrutiny of how settlements are reached is rising, and Congress is considering wider disclosure. Keep a clean log of who met whom at the agencies and elsewhere in government.
- Remember the policy can change. Commitments of three years or more will outlast the officials who accepted them. A later administration may read them strictly.
If you are the rival or the customer
Companies that depend on a merging party for distribution or supply have more leverage under this approach than under a divestiture model, because the remedy is about how they will be treated. Engage with the reviewing agency while the review is open, and be specific about the terms you need. Ask the merging parties to put commitments into your commercial agreements before closing, when they have the strongest reason to agree. Keep records of any change in treatment afterwards. Our guide to antitrust due diligence in M&A covers the buyer’s side of the same analysis.
What to watch
- Fox’s response to the Newsmax complaint and any early ruling on standing or interim relief.
- The Justice Department’s handling of Nvidia–Hugging Face and of DoorDash’s $17 billion Instacart deal.
- Whether the next conduct-based clearance is filed as a consent decree.
- Progress of the proposed Tunney Act amendments.
Bottom line
The Justice Department has said that promises about conduct can resolve merger concerns and has shown it with a $22 billion clearance. That widens the options for vertical deals in particular. The Newsmax suit shows the cost of the informal route: without a court order, commitments are easy to attack as unenforceable, and the agency’s decision does not bind private plaintiffs. Deal teams should use the new flexibility and write their commitments so that they would survive a hostile reading.
Related reading: Google ad-tech ruling: what the remedies order means for corporate counsel · Paramount settles states’ antitrust suit over the Warner Bros merger · Merging your startup.
Sources
- Bloomberg via Insurance Journal: DOJ Willing to Clear More Merger Deals Without Asset Sales (18 November 2026).
- Deadline: Newsmax files antitrust lawsuit against Fox Corp. over Roku acquisition (18 November 2026).
- The Hollywood Reporter: Newsmax sues to block Fox-Roku deal (18 November 2026).
- Competition Policy International: DOJ closes antitrust investigation as Fox completes $22 billion Roku acquisition (8 November 2026).
- MLex: US DOJ approves Fox’s $22bn acquisition of Roku with merger commitments (6 November 2026, opening paragraph only).
- Antitrust Procedures and Penalties Act (Tunney Act), 15 U.S.C. 16; Clayton Act sections 7 and 16.
- Google Trends: five-term comparison, United States, past 90 days (retrieved 19 November 2026).
Discover more from Kurums | Business Intelligence
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.