Taste Note - Amazon Management Best Sellers
Who: The A Method - Scorecards, Topgrading Interviews, and the End of Gut Hires
A Kurums Book Taste review of Who for leaders whose biggest unforced errors all walked in through the hiring process.

Why this book fits Kurums
Smart and Street put a number on the problem - the average hiring mistake costs fifteen times the salary - and built their method from the largest study of its kind: statistical analysis of thousands of executive assessments plus interviews with hundreds of CEOs and investors. The result is the hiring book operators actually implement, private equity's de facto standard.
For the Kurums HR audience it operationalizes what Work Rules proved: structure beats intuition. Where Bock gives the evidence and philosophy, Who gives the forms - scorecard, four-interview sequence, reference scripts - ready to install for any role above entry level.
What the book argues
The method opens by naming the enemy: voodoo hiring - gut calls, trick questions, the art-critic interview, the prosecutor - all variations of unstructured judgment that the data shows barely beats chance. The replacement begins with the scorecard: not a job description but a definition of success - the mission (why the role exists, in one paragraph), three to eight outcomes (specific, measurable results the hire must deliver, with numbers and dates), and competencies (behaviors required, including cultural ones). Writing the scorecard first changes everything downstream: you interview against outcomes, not resumes.
Sourcing gets its blunt chapter - referrals from your network beat ads; build the pipeline before the vacancy - but the selection engine is the four-interview sequence: the screening call (30 minutes, kill fast on career goals, strengths, weaknesses, and performance claims); the topgrading interview - the method's heart - walking the entire career chronologically, asking for every job the same five questions (what were you hired to do, what accomplishments are you proudest of, what were the low points, who were the people - and the master stroke: 'what will your boss say when we call?' which converts reference anticipation into honesty serum); the focused interviews probing specific scorecard outcomes; and reference calls run by you, from the candidate-arranged and the back-channel lists, with questions calibrated to verify the chronology.
Selection and close finish the system: grade candidates against the scorecard (the A-player bar: 90 percent chance of achieving the outcomes that only 10 percent of candidates could), decide on evidence skulls-together rather than averaging gut impressions, and sell the accepted candidate through the five F's (fit, family, freedom, fortune, fun) - because A-players have options and the offer is a sales process. The management epilogue is brief and correct: the method's value compounds only if scorecards become the operating contract you manage against after day one.
Key ideas, translated to your desk
Write the scorecard before meeting anyone
Mission, outcomes with numbers, competencies. If you can't define success on paper, every interview is a vibes exercise with furniture.
Walk the whole career, job by job
The topgrading chronology - same five questions per role - surfaces patterns no competency question reaches. Trajectories tell the truth résumés polish.
'What will your boss say?'
The threat-of-reference-check question converts self-report into near-testimony. Then actually make the calls - yourself, with the scorecard open.
Use it at work
- Mandate scorecards for every requisition above entry level; no interviews until it's signed.
- Train your top interviewers on the topgrading chronology and run it in pairs.
- Reclaim reference calls from HR admin: hiring managers call, scripts in hand, back-channels included.
- Convert scorecards into first-year management plans - the contract survives the hire.
Read it if
- Your leadership mis-hires trace back to charming interviews and skipped references.
- You are scaling and every manager invents their own hiring process.
- You run PE-backed companies where the method is becoming table stakes anyway.
You can skip it if
- You hire high-volume entry roles - the method's cost fits senior stakes.
- Work Rules-style structured process is already deep in your system; this refines it.
- You want sourcing innovation; the engine here is selection, not top-of-funnel.
This book appears in
Curated Tasting Menus that chain this title into a reading route.
Discover more from Kurums | Business Intelligence
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.